27 Comments

The German lesson for Democrats is to keep a tame conservative party around that will implement center-left policies even if they win. The FDP was punished for collaboration and is excluded from the new Bundestag. However, that ship has sailed in the US. It has sailed in the UK too where the landslide victory of Starmer Labour got less votes than the landslide defeat of Corbyn Labour. UK Conservatives simply stayed home or voted Reform. We will see what happens in France and Austria where firewall government is in effect. Democrats seem to be following the Romanian approach of using the courts to nullify elections. That may work but is extremely destabilizing. The previous Democratic strategy of boosting "extreme" candidates in the Republican primaries has already failed.

Expand full comment

Neo-liberalism is dead. The failure of the FDP to get into the Bundestag, the obliteration of Liberal Democrats in the U.K. and the total silence of Republicans to oppose Trump's trade wars is an indication of the sweep. The only voice for classic liberalism in the U.S. is the WSJ Editorial Board and even they are triangulators.

Expand full comment

Liberal Democrats in UK are the 3rd largest party in Parliament.

Expand full comment

The days of Reagan-Thatcher-Clinton-Blair are not coming back. The Liberal Democrats have 78 members in the House of Lords. They are an elite anachronism that benefited a little from rich conservatives repudiation of the Tories. They have zippo support from the working class.

Expand full comment

72 in Commons.

Expand full comment

The results of the German election and the more recent decision of Germany's mainstream political politics to abandon economic austerity are signs of support for strengthening the European Union, doubling down on opposing Putin's revanchism and advancing clean energy development. The German election and Macron's renewed popularity points to a longer term decoupling of Europe's economic and security policies from the United States as we abandon our role as leader of the free world.

Expand full comment

Should read "as we abandon our role as ATM of the free world..."

Expand full comment

Abandon our role as the ATM of the formerly free world.

Expand full comment

U.S. leadership defeated Fascism and Communism and prevented nuclear war for 80 years. The return of radical nationalism could lead to nuclear proliferation with the increasing likelihood of catastrophic consequences.

Expand full comment

Good to hear Germans too are voting down neoliberalism beginning with immigration. I would think they would do well to look at manufacturing also. I prefer Bosch tools, I pay a premium for quality, and while I've no quibble with the quality of Bosch tools manufactured in China I'd rather support workers in Germany.

Expand full comment
2dEdited

CDU is neo-liberal. And Bosch has been having QC problems. They are the only manufacturers for DEF pumps in trucks and they are not reliable.

Expand full comment

"CDU is neo-liberal" as is PPI for whom the writer works. I just wanted to see that word that has been avoided by Dem Leadership Council types.

So far all is well with my DEF. I like what comes out of the tailpipe but am horrified when I looked at what it takes to get there.

Expand full comment

My DEF system has broken 3 times. Only non-routine repairs in 13 years. Info on Bosch comes from dealer.

Expand full comment

Never thought I would enjoy reading leftist writings so much. The word abandon seems more dog whistle than accurate. Do the male and females of lions, tigers and bears abandon their young? (I couldn’t resist that line) They raise them to be independent and live on their own. They let protect them while they grow and become powerful in their own right. Nothing lasts forever. And in today’s military world, joining a fight from here is a matter of minutes or maybe hours, but not days or weeks. Nothing lasts forever and sooner or later we had to have a leader who cared more about the financial issues of this country rather than being a leader all of the time for a world of flawed humans. Economics will determine strength and leadership in the future. I believe the current administration is preparing us for that. And saving future generations from the dire consequences of today’s spend thrift parties and complacent citizens who think mainly of themselves.

Expand full comment

Trump is sloppy & his personality definitely "ruffles" <--- well, that word is too kind, feathers, & some/many of the things coming out of his mouth are wrong - however, some of what he's doing has needed to be done by someone.

Expand full comment

No human is perfect. A lot less of them favorably impact anyone or anything.

Expand full comment

😉of course no one is perfect. Those on the right however, imo, need to admit Trump is egotistical, perhaps narcissistic- but <—- that word can cancel out the words preceding it. Many politicians are the same. The left need to realize those on the right can admit to Trump’s sh*t while pointing out what he can accomplish.

And Musk is SMART. Yes, he also shoots off at the mouth - however he’s smarter than the majority of those hating him. He’s somewhere on the autism spectrum which if anyone studies that knows it might make one difficult to relate to”normally” - who is normal??? PLUS his father was a total a$$ as a dad… $ now watch Musk as he is trying to establish a relationship with his kids.

Expand full comment

The biggest worry I have about Musk is that he overdoses on ketamine. From a great distance, he seems to suffer from depression, which has led him to use a dangerous surgical anesthetic. His business, except that he's too important. So I hope that dragon doesn't kill him before his time. All the rest? Meh.

As for psychoanalyzing Trump? If one thing comforts me to a major extent, it's that he is totally serious on what needs total seriousness: nuclear weapons. Trump never, ever jokes about that at all. Past that, I see him as three parts Andrew Jackson and one part Teddy Roosevelt. He is definitely a man in a hurry who doesn't suffer fools gladly.

Expand full comment

I don't know anyone who voted for Trump who didn't realize his flaws a long time ago. Welcome to the party. Being nice, civil, or moral doesn't win wars. Being nice doesn't cut the deficit or debt. Being nice hasn't ever been responsible for the great actions in the world. In fact, joe was the perfect scam artist as he fooled those who thought he was a kindly, honest, transparent and sharp as anyone has ever seen him as president.

Do you have only normal folks in your life? Everything you mention about him is irrelevant. He hires the best and the brightish. Do you know of any of them? Research Sam Corcos. CEO and founder of Level Health and Wellness. He works a the Treasury now as a DOGE employee. Come back when you have some idea of what it takes to be successful, overcome any "flaws" and have at least a rudimentary understanding of who Sam is. You can see him in the flesh on the Laura Ingraham show.

As for his kids, they are of no concern to you nor do have any right to criticize how he relates to his kids. Another irrelevant point. Indeed, people who over come what you accuse Elon has, are to be held up as an example as one who over came his "disabilities to become the richest man in the world. Much like Sen. Fetterman who I now greatly admire.

Expand full comment

I think it's a neck-and-neck race between Bush Jr. and Joe Biden for the title of the worst president since Franklin Pierce.

Expand full comment

Jr. had two the most corrupt men ever in government. Rumsfeld and Cheney. A lot of soldiers unnecessarily die or got maimed because of them.

Expand full comment

hmmm, I wasn't being critical at all of Musk...

Expand full comment

Thanks for the clarification.

Expand full comment

I have a hard time seeing the German election as a lesson for us; the political mechanics aren't similar enough to me. If there are any lessons applicable to us, maybe they will emerge over time.

I do think there is a different lesson out of Germany, which is the increasingly shaky economic anchor of Europe. It is that the Germans have done great damage, which might become catastrophic, by sacrificing their industrial might on the altar of a headlong retreat from fossil fuel. I won't be hugely surprised if this leads to outright economic collapse. For all the surface flexibility of the European parliamentary system, it has frozen the EU in many ways.

The Germans, in particular, have a duality that has led them into two tragic wars. Highly organized, intelligent and logical, but rule-bound, stubborn, and inflexible. It works well until everything collapses and they go stark raving nuts. Maybe those flexible parliamentary systems are actually anything but flexible in their practical application? Maybe two-party systems, with their own frustrations, force clarity and action before it's too late?

And then there are the Ukrainians and the Russians, who I compare to two cancer patients fighting over a dose of morphine. Zelenskyy is their version of Al Franken, a vaudville comedian and actor who blundered upward. Putin wants to be Peter the Great, but in the end he's one of the Rus, the eastern branch of the Vikings. To this day, they are barbarians, as anyone who's been outside of Moscow or St. Petersburg realizes.

Expand full comment